Battery Safety Conference, July 28-29, 2020, Orlando FL

Cambridge EnerTech’s

Battery Safety

Battery Testing & Regulations

March 9-10, 2021


An increasing number of high-energy density batteries are entering the market. As a result it is becoming icreasingly more important for battery safety testing and regulations to advance in stride with new technologies to ensure safe battery function and consumer use. This year's Battery Safety conference program, part of the International Battery Seminar & Exhibit, will cover important battery regulations and safety testing necessary to stay up to date with large R&D advancements. Regulatory agencies and associations, cell R&D engineers and reliability engineers will discuss how they are developing robust and reliable tests for the progressively complex cell and pack designs. Maintaining battery pack stability and mitigating thermal runaway to improve safety will also be covered.

Tuesday, March 9

SAFETY REGULATIONS

9:00 am

IEC 62133-2:2021 What’s New in the Second Edition?

Cynthia Millsaps, CEO, Business & Quality, Energy Assurance LLC

IEC 62133-2 is slated to release a second edition in June of 2021.  The original scope of this project was intended to be an amendment to only address some minor revisions that the industry agreed were needed.  However, after over 3 years of work, it looks like some extensive changes and a new edition are being released.  This presentation will summarize the most important changes in the current proposals from the committee.

9:20 am

Battery Safety 

Bob Richard, PhD, President, Hazmat Safety Consulting LLC

This presentation will cover the regulatory safety initiatives that are ongoing to develop a packaging standard for lithium batteries transported by aircraft and to regulate lithium batteries based on their inherent hazards including their ability to propagate from cell to cell and how violent they react when forced into thermal runaway. The presentation will focus on innovative methods for initiating thermal runaway of trigger cells and how to prevent cell-to-cell propagation in battery packs.

9:40 am

Latest Developments with the International Fire Code Impacting the Storage of Li-Ion Batteries

George A. Kerchner, Executive Director, PRBA Rechargeable Battery Association
10:00 am Session Break - View Our Virtual Exhibit Hall

SAFETY TESTING

10:20 am

Trust, But Verify: Best Practices in Architecting and Testing Battery Safety

Christina Lampe-Onnerud, Founder and CEO, Cadenza Innovation

Fires involving the Arizona Public Service, NIO and Tesla – along with more than a dozen at South Korea power grid facilities – have heightened questions and concerns about lithium-ion (Li-ion) battery safety. Rightly so. Any number of fires is unacceptable; safety is always paramount. However, Li-ion batteries aren’t inherently unsafe. It’s how they’re architected that directly affects their safety.

10:40 am

Mitigation of Failure Propagation: A Model-Based Experimental Design

Loraine Torres-Castro, PhD, Sr Tech Staff, Power Sources R&D, Sandia Natl Labs

Large and complex battery systems require an understanding of how single-cell failure might impact an entire system. After the impacts and consequences are identified, it is essential to determine mechanisms to mitigate the effects of a single cell failure on the entire pack. These mitigations require an understanding of the heat transfer within the battery pack to identify effective and reliable strategies to reduce the risk of failure propagation. In this study, we aim to incorporate the dynamics of heat transfer during failure propagation to make use of the system thermal mass and identify effective methods to mitigate failure propagation.

Kevin Bryan, Senior Business Development Manager, Sales and Marketing, Chemtrec

Kevin Bryan will present a new system developed to assist industry with regulatory compliance and significantly minimize the burden of complying with the new lithium battery test summary mandate to meet the requirements of the tests specified in the United Nations Manual of Tests and Criteria, Part III, sub-section 38.3.

11:40 am MODERATED Q&A:

Session Wrap-Up

Panel Moderator:
Cynthia Millsaps, CEO, Business & Quality, Energy Assurance LLC
Panelists:
Bob Richard, PhD, President, Hazmat Safety Consulting LLC
George A. Kerchner, Executive Director, PRBA Rechargeable Battery Association
Christina Lampe-Onnerud, Founder and CEO, Cadenza Innovation
Loraine Torres-Castro, PhD, Sr Tech Staff, Power Sources R&D, Sandia Natl Labs
Kevin Bryan, Senior Business Development Manager, Sales and Marketing, Chemtrec
12:05 pm Session Break - View Our Virtual Exhibit Hall

PLENARY KEYNOTE PROGRAM

12:50 pm

A Micrometer Can Tell You a Lot about Li-Ion Cell Failure Modes

Jeff Dahn, FRSC, PhD, Professor of Physics and Atmospheric Science, NSERC/Tesla Canada Industrial Research Chair, Canada Research Chair, Dalhousie University

Sure, fancy methods like synchrotron X-ray tomography, scanning ultrasonic imaging, and differential capacity analysis can really help one understand the reasons for Li-ion cell failure.  However, once one understands the basic processes, measurements made with a simple micrometer can give a pretty decent idea of why Li-ion pouch cells fail.   I will use an extensive study on a large matrix of NMC622/graphite cells tested for 2.5 years at different temperatures, C-rates and depths of discharge to illustrate the importance of a simple micrometer.  

1:15 pm

U.S. Department of Energy Initiatives to Develop and Advance Lithium Batteries

David Howell, Program Manager, Acting Director, Office of Vehicle Technologies, United States Department of Energy

DOE supports research to develop EV batteries that (1) cuts battery cell cost to $60/kWh, (2) reduces battery weight and size enabling higher efficiency EVs, (3) enables 15-minute charging time, and (4) supports the development of a lithium battery recycling ecosystem. DOE chairs the Federal Consortium for Advanced Batteries that brings Federal together to accelerate the development of a robust secure domestic industrial base and ecosystem for advanced batteries.

2:00 pm MODERATED KEYNOTE Q&A:

Session Wrap-Up

Panel Moderator:
Brian Barnett, PhD, President, Battery Perspectives
Panelists:
Jeff Dahn, FRSC, PhD, Professor of Physics and Atmospheric Science, NSERC/Tesla Canada Industrial Research Chair, Canada Research Chair, Dalhousie University
David Howell, Program Manager, Acting Director, Office of Vehicle Technologies, United States Department of Energy
2:25 pm Session Break - View Our Virtual Exhibit Hall

MITIGATING THERMAL RUNAWAY

2:45 pm

Thermal Management Methods for Mitigating Thermal Runaway Propagation in Li-Ion Battery Systems

Chuanbo Yang, PhD, Senior Engineer Energy Storage, Energy Conversion & Storage Systems Center, National Renewable Energy Lab

It is becoming widely accepted that Li-ion battery energy storage systems should incorporate approved device or method to mitigate the impact of thermal runaway. This could be achieved by thermal management techniques utilizing heat conduction or heat insulation. This presentation discusses experimental and computational studies on thermal management approaches for thermal runaway control, with a particular interest on cutting-edge technology of flame-retardant forms.

3:05 pm

Diagnostic Imaging System for Electric Current Density Distribution Inside Storage Batteries

Kenjiro Kimura, Integral Geometry Science Inc.

For the first time in the world, we have succeeded in visualizing the electric current density inside batteries by deriving an analytical solution for the Inverse Problem. Based on the theory, we have developed an Image Analysis Software for diagnosing current density distribution in real-time without destruction of batteries by measuring the spatial distribution of magnetic fields

3:25 pm

Mitigation Methods for Fire and Thermal Runaway Propagation in Li-Ion Modules

Judith Jeevarajan, PhD, Research Director Electrochemical Safety, Electrochemical Safety, UL LLC

Designs to prevent propagation of thermal runaway in Li-ion modules or Li-ion cell packages is still under study. Our team has studied several materials to determine their efficacy to prevent propagation of fire and thermal runaway in Li-ion modules and Li-ion cell packages. The results of our studies will be presented during this talk.

Sarrah-Emma Querelle-Halverson, Manager Product Development, Product Development, Henkel

During this webinar, the audience will learn:

- How thermal interface materials can enable reliable battery pack thermal management and protect against thermal propagation
 
4:25 pm MODERATED Q&A:

Session Wrap-Up

Panel Moderator:
Judith Jeevarajan, PhD, Research Director Electrochemical Safety, Electrochemical Safety, UL LLC
Panelists:
Chuanbo Yang, PhD, Senior Engineer Energy Storage, Energy Conversion & Storage Systems Center, National Renewable Energy Lab
Kenjiro Kimura, Integral Geometry Science Inc.
Sarrah-Emma Querelle-Halverson, Manager Product Development, Product Development, Henkel
4:50 pm Session Break - View Our Virtual Exhibit Hall
5:10 pm Interactive Roundtable Discussions

The roundtables are informal, moderated discussions with brainstorming and interactive problem solving, allowing participants from diverse backgrounds to exchange ideas and experiences and develop future collaborations around a focused topic. Each topic is led by a moderator who ensures focused conversation around the key issues of that topic. Attendees choose to join a specific group.

ROUNDTABLE 1: Battery Materials Supply Chain

Robert M. Privette, Manager, Business Development, Rechargeable Battery Materials North America, Umicore USA Inc.
  • Financing challenges (Economics, Uncertainty, Contracting)
  • Supply & availability (Long supply chains, New capacity timelines)
  • Sustainability and lifecycle analysis (Role of renewables, Customer awareness)

ROUNDTABLE 2: The Future Direction of the Binder Market in the Wake of the Silicon Anode

Manuel Wieser, Head of Energy Division, AnteoTech
  • Silicon anode active material market is set to quadruple from 2020 to 2030
  • Performance requirements for anode binders are changing rapidly (considering low to high silicon content anode designs)
  • Binder material evolution: SBR functionalization, vs. PAA derivatization vs. return to organic solvent-based binders?
  • Surface chemistry challenge: Various silicon anode systems with different surface properties (SiOx, micro-silicon, silicon-carbon composites,…)
  • Greater diversification in future binder market or is one-size fits it all possible?​

ROUNDTABLE 3: Benefits and Challenges of Cell Manufacturing Software for Prototype and Full Scale Manufacturing

Bob Zollo, Solution Architect for Battery Testing, Keysight Technologies
  • How can software for cell formation/grading help improve cell quality and increase production yield on prototype manufacturing lines and on full scale manufacturing lines.
  • Data analytics role in helping to manufacture better cells.
  • The value of bringing and test data from characterization labs together with manufacturing data collected from upstream processes, formation/grading, and downstream processes.

ROUNDTABLE 4: Commercially Viable Process for Surface Conditioning of High-Ni Cathodes

Feng Wang, PhD, Materials Scientist, Energy & Photon Sciences Directorate, Brookhaven National Lab
  • What is the start-of-the-art and next generation of high-Ni cathodes? And what are other options to further push on Li-storage capacity  -- ultra-high Ni, Co-free, or other new cathode systems?
  • Besides thermal instability, safety-related issues, what are other key barriers hindering the commercial use of high-Ni cathodes?
  • What are the most commonly employed processes in industry for surface conditioning of high-Ni cathodes?
  • What are other processes that are promising for industrial use in stabilizing high-Ni cathodes?
5:55 pm Close of Day

Wednesday, March 10

PREVENTING BATTERY FAILURE

9:00 am

Influence of Different Thermal Runaway Triggers on the Failing Behavior of Automotive Lithium-Ion Batteries

Christiane Essl, Researcher, Battery Safety, VIRTUAL VEHICLE Research GmbH

This presentation shows the setup and results of three different thermal runaway triggers on modern battery cells in a custom-made TR reactor. It focuses on the trigger overtemperature, overcharge and nail-penetration. The investigated cell types are state-of-the-art automotive cells. The results are discussed in three main categories: thermal behavior, ventgas production and ventgas composition. The findings are supposed to be valuable for battery pack designer, testing institutions and regulations.

9:20 am

Comparative Analysis of Thermal Runaway Heat Rates as a Function of Trigger Mechanism and Cell Format

Peter J. Hughes, Battery Thermal Engineering Graduate CO-OP, NASA Johnson Space Center
9:40 am

Lithium-Ion Thermal Runaway – Experiments & Models for Detection and Consequences

Erik Archibald, UT Fire Research Group, University of Texas at Austin

A summary of thermal runaway detection and consequence modeling from the UT Austin Fire Research Group. Failure detection has been performed using load cells, temperatures, gas sensors and ultrasonic systems. Multiple models have been developed to understand the thermal runaway process and its consequences. Mathematical models are presented to predict cell thermal runaway and cell-to-cell runaway propagation. Reduced order models and computational fluid dynamics models are used to model gas release, fire and explosion hazards.  Multiple models span scales ranging from single cell to fire and explosion consequences on people and structures.

Gunnar O'Connor, Senior Product Development Engineer, Latent Heat Solutions

As lithium-ion batteries advance, they have become increasingly energy dense and much of their design is focused on preventing and controlling possible thermal runaway. This becomes more important in applications such as energy storage system (ESS) and portable power systems. This presentation will demonstrate LHS’ XTS material which is custom designed to capture ejected thermal energy and to quench flaming that occurs while also improving the life of the battery pack. 

11:00 am MODERATED Q&A:

Session Wrap-Up

Panel Moderator:
Christiane Essl, Researcher, Battery Safety, VIRTUAL VEHICLE Research GmbH
Panelists:
Peter J. Hughes, Battery Thermal Engineering Graduate CO-OP, NASA Johnson Space Center
Erik Archibald, UT Fire Research Group, University of Texas at Austin
Gunnar O'Connor, Senior Product Development Engineer, Latent Heat Solutions
11:25 am Close of Battery Safety Conference